Monday Night Football home underdogs: myth vs. evidence

We earn a commission if you open a Bovada account through links on this page.

There’s no good evidence that betting every home underdog on Monday Night Football still gives you an edge. The angle dates from the years when Monday was the NFL’s only weekly prime-time game. Widely cited research on home underdogs doesn’t look at Monday games separately, so treat Monday night as one detail in your handicapping and nothing more.

Where the idea came from

Monday Night Football first aired on ABC on September 21, 1970, with the Jets playing the Browns. Until ESPN began airing Sunday night games in 1987, Monday was the league’s only regular weekly prime-time game, so a big national audience watched the same game every week.

The theory went like this. A big national audience brought in a lot of casual bettors, and casual bettors tend to back favorites and well-known teams. If books raised the favorite’s price to deal with that money, the home underdog would get a point or two more than it deserved.

That’s a sensible story. The records passed around to support it are harder to trust. They change depending on which seasons someone starts from, and they often don’t say which lines they were graded against.

What research says about home underdogs

One widely cited study is by economist Steven Levitt, published in The Economic Journal in 2004. He looked at picks from a handicapping contest run by an online sportsbook during the 2001-02 NFL season, and at game results going back to 1980.

In the contest, 60.6% of picks went on favorites, and 68.2% went on the road team when it was favored. Picks on home underdogs won 57.7% of the time that season.

One season is a small sample, though. Over the 21 seasons from 1980 to 2001, road favorites covered only 46.7% of the time across 1,483 games. That means home underdogs in those games covered at most 53.3% of the time, barely above the 52.38% you need at -110.

Levitt concluded that books shade prices against the teams bettors like, and accept lopsided action to do it. He also wrote that bookmakers “appear to have distorted prices as much as possible without allowing a simple strategy of always betting on underdogs to become profitable.”

None of the paper’s breakdowns look at Monday games on their own, so it says nothing about Monday night in particular.

Why Monday night is a different market now

Monday night now shares prime time with weekly Sunday and Thursday night games, and Monday Night Football itself moved from ABC to ESPN in 2006. The single showcase game the angle grew up around no longer exists in that form.

How closely books watch a game matters too. A study of NFL lines from 2007 to 2021, published in the Journal of Economics and Finance, found that games drawing less public attention saw more frequent and larger line moves. The authors suggested oddsmakers focus their limited resources on the most visible games.

If that’s right, a nationally televised Monday game is one of the games books price most carefully. That makes it a harder place to find a soft number than a quiet early-afternoon game on Sunday.

How to check the trend yourself

If someone quotes you a Monday home underdog record, you can rebuild it from past scores and closing lines:

  1. List every Monday night game for the seasons you want to test, with the home team’s closing spread.
  2. Keep only the games where the home team was the underdog, and decide ahead of time what to do with pick’ems.
  3. Grade each game against that closing spread as a cover, a loss or a push.
  4. Work out the win rate with pushes left out, and compare it with 52.38%, the break-even rate at -110.
  5. Split the seasons into an older half and a recent half, and see whether the result holds in both.

The sample will be small. In Levitt’s 21 seasons of data, the road team was favored in 1,483 of 4,793 games, a bit under a third. With only one or two Monday games a week, that leaves a handful of Monday home underdogs each season.

Say you find 50 of them over the past decade and they went 30-20 against the spread. That’s 60%, which looks strong. But a fair coin comes up heads 30 or more times in 50 flips about 10% of the time, so a record like that could well be luck.

Check the price as well as the points. A home underdog at +3 with -120 odds has to win 54.55% of the bets that don’t push to break even (120 ÷ 220), while +3.5 at -110 needs 52.38%. A record that assumes every bet was made at -110 can make an angle look better than it really was. Our piece on 55 percent winners explains why a few percentage points matter so much.

How to use Monday night spots

Handicap a Monday game the way you would any other. Make your own number for the spread, then see whether the home underdog’s line is better than yours by enough to cover the -110 price.

Night games do have one well-studied quirk. A 2013 study in the journal SLEEP found West Coast teams beat the spread in 70 of 106 night games against East Coast teams from 1970 to 2011. That’s a small sample spread over four decades, so use it as a minor adjustment. Our road team betting guide covers travel and time zones in more detail.

Monday games also give injury news and weather forecasts an extra day to come out, so lines can keep moving through the weekend. If you like a Monday home underdog, compare prices before you bet. Our guide to anticipating line shifts covers when to bet early and when to wait.

Bovada is an offshore sportsbook with no US state license. Our Bovada review explains what that means for you as a customer.

Bovada posts spreads, totals and moneylines for every Monday night game, so you can compare its price on the home underdog with your own number. If you live in a state with legal online sportsbooks, a state-licensed book gives you more protection, because it answers to a state regulator if something goes wrong.

Affiliate link. 18+ (or older where your state requires). Not available in 19 states and Washington, DC.

Only bet what you’ve set aside to lose. If gambling has stopped being fun, call or text 1-800-MY-RESET (1-800-697-3738) for free, confidential help, 24/7, or chat online with the National Problem Gambling Helpline.

Sources